Get a Quote
Home / Blog / Biofilm carriers
Deep dive

Biofilm carriers compared: MBBR, bio balls, sponge and hanging media

Every attached-growth carrier does the same thing — hold biology in the tank — and they differ in one number: how much protected surface they carry per cubic metre, and whether the tank can keep them moving.

Nuoweisen Environmental · updated 21 October 2026 · reading time about 11 minutes
Suspended ball biofilm carriers
Suspended ball media - a larger protected surface carrier

Why attached growth at all

Suspended activated sludge is a good process that fails in a predictable way: when the load rises, the biomass washes out of the clarifier faster than it grows. Attached growth changes that. The biofilm holds on to the surface, so the solids retention time is set by the carrier rather than by the clarifier, and slow-growing organisms — the nitrifiers in particular — can establish.

That is why carriers are the standard answer to two situations: an existing tank that has to take more load, and a plant that has to nitrify reliably at a temperature it was not designed for. See what is MBBR for the process view.

The three families of carrier

FamilyBehaviourWhere it belongs
Moving carriersFluidised by aeration, kept in the tank by a retention screenAerobic tanks. The default choice for a capacity upgrade
Fixed hanging mediaMounted on a frame, water flows pastAnoxic and anaerobic zones, low-energy plants, tanks that cannot take a screen
Fixed or stacked mediaInstalled as a bed or stackTrickling filters, submerged aerated filters, polishing stages

MBBR media: K1 to K5 and the PE series

Names you will see in a tender or a quoteMBBR media · MBBR carrier · moving bed biofilm carrier · moving bed biofilm media · biofilm carrier media · bio media · bio carrier · K1 media · K3 carrier · K5 carrier · PE01–PE08 carrier · suspended packing · porous suspended ball · spherical bio carrier · moving bed ball · bio ball

The moving bed biofilm reactor carrier is the workhorse. Our range runs K1 through K5 in HDPE, from Φ10 × 10 mm up to Φ25 × 5 mm, with the perforation count rising across the series — 4–5 holes on K1 through to 64 holes on K5 — and specific surface area from above 800 m²/m³ on the small types to above 1,000 on the high-surface variants.

PropertyPublished value
TypesK1, K2, K3, K4, K5 (Φ10 × 10 to Φ25 × 5 mm) plus the PE01–PE08 series
Material and densityHDPE, density approximately 0.96 g/cm³; PE series 0.94–0.97 g/cm³
Specific surface areaAbove 800–1,000 m²/m³ for K types; above 600–1,300 m²/m³ across the PE series
PorosityAbove 85–90%
Packing densityFrom more than 76,000 up to 850,000 pieces per cubic metre depending on type
Biofilm formation3–15 days
Nitrification rate400–1,200 g N/m³·d
BOD / COD oxidation2,000–15,000 g/m³·d
Service temperature5–60 °C
Service lifeBeyond 15 years

The full column-by-column explanation of what each of those numbers changes is in MBBR media specification, and the product is MBBR moving bed media.

A high specific surface area is only useful if the water can actually flow past it. Two carriers advertising the same surface area can behave completely differently once fluidised, because what matters is the surface that stays reachable — not the surface the moulding has.

Ball and sphere carriers

Where the tank is shallow, the aeration is weak, or the duty wants a larger protected volume, ball formats take over.

Sponge carriers

Polyurethane sponge media holds a very high biomass per unit volume because the internal structure is protected on all sides. It suits high-load duties where tank volume is fixed and the biology has to be concentrated. The trade-off is that a sponge carrier is harder to fluidise than a rigid one and needs adequate aeration to avoid compacting, and the internal volume can eventually clog with inert material in high-suspended-solids service.

Hanging media

Hanging media is fixed on a frame and does not depend on aeration to stay in place. That makes it the right answer in three situations: anoxic and anaerobic zones, plants with a tight energy budget, and retrofits where fitting a retention screen is impractical.

ProductCharacterTypical duty
Combined packing mediaSemi-soft composite, also sold as contact oxidation packingGeneral aerobic and anoxic retrofits
Elastic packingWave-form elastic strands, high void ratio, resists compactionAerobic tanks with high solids, and duties where a fixed carrier must not blind
Biological rope mediaBraided rope or belt on a frameLong, narrow tanks and channels; low-energy installations
Carbon fibre water grassFine carbon fibre strands, very high surface area to volumeAnoxic and anaerobic zones, polishing, and ecological water bodies

Hanging media cannot be replaced without draining the tank, and the frame has to be designed with the media rather than afterwards. Both of those are good reasons to specify generously the first time.

Fill fraction: the number that ties it together

Fill fraction — sometimes called dosing ratio — is the percentage of reactor volume occupied by carriers at rest. It is the single number that converts a biological requirement into an order quantity, and it is almost always specified wrong.

The method is three steps:

  1. Work out the load to be removed for each parameter — BOD, COD, ammonia.
  2. Divide each by the design removal rate for that parameter and take the largest carrier volume.
  3. Check that volume against the fill fraction window for your reactor.

The worked example, including the 15–67% window, is in MBBR media calculation. The MBBR media calculator runs the arithmetic and checks the window for you.

The upper end of the window is not a target. Above it, carriers cannot be kept moving by the aeration available, the retention screen blinds, and the effective surface area falls — you have paid for surface you cannot reach.

Choosing between them

  1. Is there aeration in the zone? If no, hanging media. If yes, continue.
  2. Is the tank deep enough to fluidise the carrier you want? Shallow tanks push you toward larger, lighter carriers or hanging media.
  3. What load has to be removed, and at what temperature? Run the calculation; the answer gives the carrier volume, not the carrier type.
  4. Can the existing aeration feed the extra biomass? More biology means more oxygen demand. If it cannot, the carriers will make dissolved oxygen worse.
  5. Can the clarifier return the extra solids? The second check that kills retrofits. Neither is about the carrier.

If the question behind the question is whether carriers will fix the plant at all, MBBR vs activated sludge is the honest comparison to read next.

Questions buyers ask

What is fill fraction in MBBR and why does it matter?

Fill fraction is the percentage of reactor volume occupied by carriers at rest. It matters because it is the bridge between the biology you need and the concrete you already have: too little and the reactor cannot remove the load, too much and the carriers cannot be kept moving, the screen blinds and the surface area you paid for is unreachable. It is an output of the load calculation, in the 15-67% window, not a figure to pick from a catalogue.

Are bio balls the same as MBBR media?

They are both attached-growth carriers, but they are different tools. MBBR media is small, has a high specific surface area, and is designed to fluidise freely in an aerated tank - which is why it is dosed by fill fraction. A suspended bio ball is larger, with a protected internal volume, and suits shallower tanks, weaker aeration, or duties where a bigger carrier will not wash out through the screen.

When should I use hanging media instead of moving carriers?

When there is no aeration to keep carriers in suspension - anoxic and anaerobic zones are the clear case - or when the plant has to run on minimal energy. Hanging media is also easier to justify in a tank that has to be emptied rarely, because it can be designed on a frame that lifts out. The trade-off is that it cannot be replaced without draining.

Can I mix two types of carrier in one reactor?

It is done, and sometimes deliberately, to create a range of protected surface sizes. But the sizing gets harder: specific surface area, fluidisation behaviour and the fill fraction all differ per type, so the calculation has to be run per type and then checked for the total that the aeration can actually keep moving. Mixing types without redoing the aeration check is how reactors end up with carriers in piles.

How long do MBBR carriers last?

Our HDPE carriers are published at a service life beyond 15 years. They are not a wear item in the way a diffuser membrane is: the carrier is not consumed, and provided it is kept fluidised and the screen is maintained, it will outlast most of the plant around it.

More in this series

Each guide takes a whole product family and works through the alternatives.

Wastewater treatment media: the complete buyer's guide →Tube settlers and lamella plates explained →Disc, tube and plate diffusers compared →Fibre ball, comet fibre and fibre bundle →

Carrier volume from your load, not from a table

Send the reactor volume, the influent and the effluent target. We return the carrier type, the volume and the fill fraction check.

Ask for a specification checkNo obligation - response within 24h (working days)